Theme 37 of 43
Sanctions, Offshore Structures and the Architecture of Corporate Impunity
Of the 988 companies barred from contracting with any public body in Brazil, 213 remain cleared to bid in the federal government's supplier registry.
Registries rarely read together map the border between what the Brazilian state knows about corporate misconduct and what it actually does about it. The ICIJ Offshore Leaks database exposes who moves wealth through opaque jurisdictions; international sanctions lists (OFAC, UN, European Union, OpenSanctions) mark who has been formally punished abroad; the federal audit court's debarment registry and the Comptroller General's registries of punished companies (CEIS and CNEP) record who is banned from public contracting at home; and the federal attorney general's active debt registry measures how much the state has already acknowledged it is owed and has not collected. Cross-referenced, they reveal a funnel that narrows disproportionately: abundant information at the entrance, almost no consequence at the exit.
1,532 Brazilian offshore companies — and Panama leads
The ICIJ Offshore Leaks database holds 814,344 offshore entities leaked from corporate service providers worldwide. Filtering by country, 1,532 have a declared link to Brazil, alongside 4,847 Brazilian individuals registered as shareholders, directors or beneficiaries. The distribution across jurisdictions is not random: Panama and the British Virgin Islands hold 70% of Brazilian structures, and Nevada stands out — not a Caribbean tax haven, but a US state whose corporate law permits equivalent opacity.
| Jurisdiction | Entities | % of BR total |
|---|---|---|
| Panama | 589 | 38.4% |
| British Virgin Islands | 492 | 32.1% |
| Nevada (USA) | 132 | 8.6% |
| Niue | 91 | 5.9% |
| Seychelles | 79 | 5.2% |
| Samoa | 43 | 2.8% |
| Bahamas | 33 | 2.2% |
| Cayman Islands | 21 | 1.4% |
Nevada ranks ahead of the Seychelles and the Bahamas as a destination for Brazilian offshore structures — corporate opacity is no monopoly of tropical islands.
213 companies barred nationwide remain cleared in the federal supplier registry
SICAF, the registry that clears companies to sell to the federal government, held 962,016 records in July 2026, of which 826,106 were cleared to bid — 640,060 distinct companies, the rest being individuals. The federal audit court's (TCU) debarment list, those barred from contracting after a ruling by the court, holds 117 companies. But the TCU is not the only exit door. The Registry of Ineligible and Suspended Companies (CEIS) and the National Registry of Punished Companies (CNEP), kept by the Comptroller General (CGU), gather sanctions imposed by federal, state and municipal bodies: on 24 October 2026, 7,559 companies had a sanction in force in them.
| Registry | Count |
|---|---|
| SICAF records | 962,016 |
| Companies cleared to bid (distinct tax IDs) | 640,060 |
| Companies with a sanction in force in CEIS or CNEP | 7,559 |
| — declared ineligible by some public body | 1,727 |
| — barred in every sphere and branch of government | 988 |
| Companies debarred by the TCU | 117 |
| Leniency agreements signed with the CGU (companies) | 52 (139) |
Matching tax IDs, 3,711 of the 7,559 sanctioned companies appear as cleared in SICAF. Much of that is lawful: a ban imposed by a city hall applies to that body or that sphere, not to the federal government. The reach of each sanction, however, is on record. Of the 988 companies barred in every sphere and every branch of government, 213 are listed as cleared to bid in the federal registry — all with a sanction that began before the SICAF snapshot date and remains in force until at least October 2026. Registration is not a contract: the buying agency should still check CEIS before signing. But clearance is the first filter, and for one in five of these companies it did not work.
| Reach of the sanction | Sanctioned companies | Cleared in SICAF | % |
|---|---|---|---|
| Every sphere, every branch | 988 | 213 | 21.6% |
| Every branch in the sanctioning body's sphere | 2,983 | 2,067 | 69.3% |
| Sanctioning body's sphere and branch | 643 | 338 | 52.6% |
| Sanctioning body only | 1,551 | 1,147 | 74.0% |
| Reach not reported | 2,288 | 369 | 16.1% |
One in five companies barred from contracting with any public body in the country is still cleared in the federal supplier registry.
R$ 67.7 billion in unpaid severance fund, with 1% of debtors holding half
Federal active debt tied to severance fund (FGTS) contributions totals R$ 67.7 billion across 532,707 filings — money that should sit in workers' individual accounts and that the state has formally recognised as owed. Concentration is extreme: the largest 1% of filings accounts for 45.8% of the entire value. And 35.9% of filings have never been taken to court, remaining in administrative collection without corresponding legal action.
| Indicator | Value |
|---|---|
| Consolidated value | R$ 67.7 billion |
| Filings | 532,707 |
| Concentration in largest 1% | 45.8% of value |
| Filings taken to court | 64.1% |
| Filings without legal action | 35.9% |
Half the severance-fund debt sits with 1% of debtors — scattered collection across the other 99% consumes state capacity to recover the other half.
Powerful cross-references
- Offshore × Jurisdiction: 70% of Brazilian structures sit in Panama and the British Virgin Islands.
- Nevada × Caribbean: a US state hosts more Brazilian offshore entities than the Seychelles or Bahamas.
- SICAF × CEIS/CNEP: 213 of the 988 companies barred in every sphere remain cleared in the federal registry.
- TCU × CGU: the audit court debarred 117 companies; the CGU registries list 7,559 companies with a sanction in force.
- Severance fund × Concentration: 1% of debtors account for 45.8% of R$ 67.7 billion.
- Debt × Litigation: 35.9% of filings never became a court case.
- Sanction × Term: audit-court debarment averages five years, after a process that takes as many again.
Explanatory hypotheses
The asymmetry between available information and applied sanction has a structural, not moral, explanation: detecting irregularity is cheap and automatable — cross-referencing databases, comparing tax IDs, spotting patterns — while punishing it demands due process, adversarial proceedings and full defence, each with its own human cost and timeline. The result is a funnel where detection capacity grows with technology while punishment capacity stays bounded by headcount and procedural duration. The concentration of severance-fund debt further suggests a prioritisation problem: if half the value sits in 1% of filings, scattered collection distributes effort in inverse proportion to fiscal return.
Public policy implications
Prioritising collection by largest debtors — rather than treating all filings as equivalent — would recover half the value with a fraction of the administrative effort. Automatically integrating CEIS, CNEP and the TCU debarment list into SICAF at the clearance stage, respecting the recorded reach of each sanction, would close the window in which a punished company remains listed — today, 213 companies barred nationwide. And routinely cross-referencing ICIJ data and international sanctions lists against corporate ownership records would allow preventive identification of public suppliers whose ownership structures sit in opaque jurisdictions.